10 Fresh Seafood Restaurants in Naples Florida

Are you a seafood lover? Then you have to try these 10 amazing seafood restaurants in Naples Florida!

Thanks to Naples’ enviable location on the Gulf Coast, the city has easy access to delicious, fresh seafood.

Combine that with the many talented chefs in the area, and you have lots of tasty seafood restaurants in Naples.

But dining out is one of the top things to do in Naples, everyone’s favorite form of entertainment.

And when your time is limited and you want fresh seafood in just the right setting, these Top 10 are the best seafood restaurants in Naples, running the gamut from sophisticated and modern to traditional and casual.

Dig your toes in the sand over a Seafood Napoleon, enjoy a smoked fish dip with a crisp rose on a lazy afternoon downtown, or watch the sun set over your raw seafood tower along the Cocahatchee River.

Simply put, if you’re searching for the best seafood restaurants in Naples, Florida, this guide has 10 great recommendations you absolutely have to try.

10 Seafood Restaurants in Naples Florida

Sails Restaurant

301 5th Ave S, Naples

When it comes to amazing Naples seafood restaurants, there’s one place that tops the list — Sails Restaurant, one of the best restaurants in Naples.

Between the sophisticated atmosphere and expertly prepared meals, what more could you ask for in a place that’s all about the frutti de mare?

Their name says it all.

You’ll notice the sleek leather seats and elegant white tablecloths immediately as you enter Sails. But take a peek at the menu and things just get better.

Choose between a prix fixe tasting menu or an a la carte menu. The prix fixe menu has four amazing courses, while the a la cart menu allows you to have a bit more flexibility.

The lobster ravioli, wood-grilled octopus, and sticky toffee pudding are all crowd favorites.

Captain & Krewe Seafood Market & Raw Bar

629 8th St S, Naples

With it’s fresh fish market good looks and tasty cuisine, Captain & Krewe is one of the top fresh fish restaurants in Naples Florida.

The casual setting just off 5th Avenue South and across from Cambier Park has indoor and outdoor seating, and is a perfect afternoon refuel stop when you’re shopping in Naples, or just hanging out with friends over some wine.

Share a few small plates among friends — the charred NOLA oysters and Fish Sampler of salmon, smoked fish dip, tuna and seafood salad are perfect shareables.

Or try the fresh catch of the day served seared or blackened and paired with a nice selection from their wine or craft beer list for a light lunch .

BALEEN Naples

LaPlaya Beach & Golf Resort, 9891 Gulf Shore Dr, Naples

If you’re looking for Naples seafood restaurants that are beachfront, BALEEN Naples is a great option. Nestled in the La Playa Beach & Golf Resort, BALEEN Naples is open for all three meals of the day – although if you’re looking for seafood, lunch or dinner is your best bet.

At both of these meals, you’ll have a wide variety of seafood dishes to choose from.

Order the blackened Gulf grouper, the risotto with forest mushrooms and Maine lobster tail, or the local Gulf catch with swiss chard and artichoke.

And don’t forget to pair your meal with a fun cocktail!

If you’d like to take your dining experience up a notch, you can book a private, romantic “toes in the sand” beachfront table.

The Turtle Club Restaurant

The Vanderbilt Beach Resort, 9225 Gulf Shore Dr, Naples

The Turtle Club restaurant is another fabulous beachfront spot with the best seafood in Naples Florida.

Picture this: you have a scrumptious seafood dish in front of you, and you’re watching a fiery colored sun dip below the horizon and listening to the waves crashing on the shore.

Sounds perfect, right?

To make your time at the Turtle Club even more amazing, the food here is known for being some of the best in town.

The famous oysters “Turtlefeller,” the Sea Harvest, and the Roasted Lobster Tail and Petite filet are all worth a try. For lighter fare, try the Seafood Napoleon.

Finally, to round out your The Turtle Club Restaurant experience, you’ll want to order a rum cocktail or two.

This Naples seafood restaurant boasts a micro-brewed rum blend that has been locally brewed specifically for them!

The Tipsy Turtle, the Tropical Passion, and the Miami Vice are all insanely good.

The Bay House

799 Walkerbilt Rd, Naples

While The Bay House isn’t beachfront like some on this list of best seafood restaurants in Naples Florida, it is one of those Naples restaurants on the water that’s perfect for a special occasion, an impromptu stop after work, or one of the best brunches in Naples on Sunday!

Located on a lovely stretch of the Cocohatchee River, The Bay House has a prime piece of real estate and the ambiance to match.

You’ll have an amazing view of the Cocohatchee Wildlife Preserve — and the wildlife that live there — during your meal whether you dine indoors or out.

And while the views are certainly a highlight of The Bay House, the food is even better.

Try the Hamachi crudo with yuzu, the high rise seafood tower, the Sea BLT, or the Paris bistro-style lobster and frites.

And of course, October to May is Florida Stone Crab season, and The Bay House does them so well.

Truluck’s

698 4th Ave S, Naples

Despite the dozens of seafood restaurants Naples FL has to offer, Truluck’s has found some unique ways to distinguish itself from the competition.

First, Truluck’s is serious about its Florida Stone Crabs.

The restaurant actually has its own team of professional crabbers to make sure that they only serve the best of the best (in season, of course).

Truluck’s also stands out with their unique from the source fish tale, which tells you exactly where your fish comes from.

And while this is certainly interesting, this info also highlights Truluck’s embracing of sustainable and high-quality practices.

All this additional effort means that Truluck’s has some of the best seafood in Naples – and you simply have to try it.

You can and should opt for the fresh Florida Stone Crab claws (at least two to share), and the Mediterranean Branzino and the Hawaiian Ahi Tuna are divine as well.

The Claw Bar at Bellesera Resort

221 9th St S, Naples

Located inside the Bellasera Resort in downtown Naples, Florida,

The Claw Bar features boatloads of incredible seafood cuisine in a relaxed, elegant setting inside or out.

Start with the Miso Clam Chowder or fresh oysters on the half-shell — you can watch your Iced Seafood Tower being prepared in the open kitchen.

The Claw Bar is one of the finest Naples seafood restaurants with an extensive menu of fresh and locally sourced seasonal fish.

Dine inside in the beautiful dining room, outside on the covered patio, or reserve seats at the raw bar.

Enjoy live music upstairs in The London Club dining room as you sip a cocktail from the bar or from their excellent wine list.

Mr. Big Fish Seafood & Bar

754 Neapolitan Way, Naples

This neighborhood seafood gem tucked away in a Park Shore strip mall just off Rte. 41 is one of Naples’ best seafood restaurants.

The pretty setting off Neapolitan Way is obscured by foliage, keeping it hidden from many a seafood fan.

What started out as our go-to place for a glass of wine and something light when we weren’t all that hungry, has turned into a bit of a habit.

The first 5 or 6 visits all we ordered were the Chardonnay Clams — little neck clams done in white wine and and garlic butter broth were the perfect answer every time!

We’ve since moved on to their fresh fish prepared in a number of ways and you will too.

From fresh Florida Mahi-Mahi and Gulf Snapper to Chilean Sea Bass and Pacific coast Salmon prepared grilled, sautéed, broiled, parmcrusted or blackened, Mr. Big Fish never disappoints!

Swan River Seafood Restaurant  

3741 Tamiami Trail N, Naples

Not only is Swan River Seafood a fun nautical-themed restaurant with a lobster boat raw bar, but the fresh seafood is brought in daily and it’s out of this world.

We’re often surprised to not find Swan River applauded more often but if you’re looking for good seafood restaurants in Naples, Florida, this is one of the best.

It’s super casual and New England-y, and has the largest selection of fresh seafood in Naples to boot.

Go to enjoy freshly shucked oysters and a glass of wine at the raw bar, or order something from the sea at a comfy table inside or  a booth out on the patio.

If you’re in town between October and May, you have to have fresh local Stone Crabs. And the fish dip is a great appetizer!

This is not a large venue so be sure to make a reservation.

USS Nemo

3745 Tamiami Trail N, Naples

It’s surprising that two of Naples’ best seafood restaurants are located right next door to each other, but other than serving the freshest seafood, that’s where any similarity ends.

So if you’re looking for great seafood with a more upscale atmosphere, stay to the right and dine at USS Nemo.

Despite its porthole windows lining the outside wall, any sign of kitsch ends there.

The Asian-fusion cuisine at USS Nemo is always fresh and beautifully prepared.

The Miso Broiled Sea Bass in citrus-ginger butter sauce is their signature dish, but the Lobster and Shrimp Pappardelle Pasta is out of this world — so light and delicious and creamy, we dare you to stop eating it.

They’re also open for lunch and their Poke bowls are perfect for a light and satisfying entree.

You’ll need a reservation, and during season book well in advance.

Whether you’re looking for a beachfront restaurant with great seafood or a delectable raw bar to graze for hours, all of these 10 seafood restaurants in Naples FL will definitely satisfy your craving for something briny.

---