Where to Eat the Best Burger in Naples, Florida

by Lori Sorrentino

There’s no doubt that Naples is a great food city, but if you’re looking for the best burger in Naples Florida…we’ve got what you need, my carnivore friend!

With over 700 great restaurants and eateries in Naples serving everything from fresh local seafood to authentic Neapolitan pizza, great dining is never far away.

But where do you go when you’re craving a perfect juicy burger, or maybe a cheeseburger in paradise? Luckily, there are quite a few burger joints in Naples from which to choose.

If you’re looking for a place with a wide variety of burger options, Brooks Burgers is the place to go.

If you’re all about the beef, pay a visit to Jimmy P’s Charred for the highest quality meat in town.

Want a classic burger at its finest? Head to The Rooster.

Simply put, if you’re looking for the best burger in Naples, this guide has you covered — with 8 of the best burgers in Paradise!

Who Has The Best Burger in Naples, Florida?

Brooks Burgers

If you Google where to get the best burger in Naples, Florida, Brooks Burgers will always be at the top.

Though it’s just a little over 10 years old, Brooks is already a local institution, and lauded by many including The Food Network as one of the best burgers in the country, so there’s no denying it’s one of the best burgers in Naples!

As a matter of fact, this neighborhood burger place is so popular, they now have three locations spread throughout the city.

Whether you’re looking for a traditional burger or a unique twist, Brooks Burgers has loads of options. Enjoy the flavorful Korean burger, the infamous Donut burger, or the slightly sweet Fig and Fine (my personal fave) — with its perfect marriage of caramelized onions, goat cheese crumbles, and fig jam.

And while the donut burger is what originally draws in new foodie customers, the twice baked burger is actually the most popular order.

With herbed cream cheese, crispy potato sticks, and crispy bacon, it’s a slight, yet fantastic change to a classic burger.

If you yourself are not a carnivore, the menu at Brooks will accommodate you too with all sorts of sandwiches and other hand helds.

Be sure and order one of their famous shakes — slurries — to go with your burger!

Now with 4 locations:

845 Vanderbilt Beach Rd, Naples
330 9th Street South, Naples
2220 Logan Blvd N, Naples
5375 Hibiscus Dr, Naples

Harold’s Place

If you’ve never been to Harold’s Place in central Naples, you’re in for a treat.

It’s one of the hidden gems in Naples, and a favorite Sunday karaoke hotspot!

But the food and drinks are what keeps drawing the locals.

Harold’s Place has a few different amazing burgers to choose from, like the Barbecue Cheddar burger, the Black Angus sliders, or Harold’s classic hamburger.

But what sets the burgers at Harold’s Place apart are the many additional burger toppings.

You can add everything from a second burger patty to spicy jalapeños to a fried egg to make your burger just how you like it (for a bit extra, of course).

Gulf Coast Inn, 2555 Tamiami Trail N, Naples

D’Amico’s The Continental

D’Amico’s The Continental is actually known for its high-quality steaks.

This pretty much guarantees that the ground beef used in the burgers is also top-notch.

So while most diners will likely order a filet mignon or a New York strip, you won’t be disappointed by the burgers here.

There’s just one burger on D’Amico’s The Continental’s menu: The Continental Burger but who’s counting when it’s done perfectly. Considering how amazing this single burger is, there’s really no need to add more to the menu.

With the excellent base of first-rate meat, everything is already off to a good start.

Then, the awesome toppings, including the bacon, caramelized onions, and mac sauce, just take everything to the next level.

In other words, when looking for a great Naples burger, don’t overlook D’Amico’s The Continental for brunch or dinner.

1205 3rd Street South, Naples

The Bay House Restaurant

While the Bay House Restaurant is one of the best seafood restaurants in Naples known primarily for their surf and turf-inspired menu, you can also get a fantastic burger at this Naples restaurant.

Like The Continental, there’s just one burger on the menu at The Bay House Restaurant, but this one plate alone is worth a visit.

First of all, there’s the meat. The Butcher’s Tavern burger boasts a top-notch blend of ground short rib, brisket, and sirloin.

Then, there are all of the toppings stacked on top of the meaty goodness.

Bacon, pimento cheese, butter lettuce, pickled red onion, and The Bay House Restaurant’s fabulous secret sauce round out this fantastic burger.

799 Walkerbilt Rd, Naples

LowBrow Pizza & Beer

I know what you’re thinking. Why is a pizza place on this list of where to get the best burger in Naples?

We have two words for you: bovine love. Lowbrow Pizza’s Bovine Love burger made with tasty BBQ brisket is delicious. every. single. time!

And when it’s topped off with pimento cheese, slaw, and secret sauce, it’s the perfect blend of smoky, juicy, and fresh. Oh my.

The menu at LowBrow is of course geared to pizza, but there’s plenty to satisfy everyone.

And If you like, order a cold beer to wash down your awesome burger.

Try one of the local brews from some of Naples’ best breweries like Naples Beach Brewery, Riptide Brewing, or Bone Hook Brewing Co.

3148 Tamiami Trail E, Naples

The Rooster Food + Drink

Like LowBrow Pizza & Beer, The Rooster Food + Drink isn’t primarily a burger spot.

It’s actually one of our favorite Naples breakfast places, and brunch too.

But the Butter burger is so good that many consider it to be the best burger in Naples, Florida.

At first glance, the Butter burger doesn’t seem like anything special — just a burger with American cheese, lettuce, and tomatoes.

But when you take your first bite, you’ll get what the fuss is all about. It’s the thought and attention that goes into the crispy brioche, the juicy patty, and all of the flavorful toppings.

Spruce up your butter burger even more with bacon, mushrooms, onions, avocado, or a fried egg.

Empire Plaza, 600 Goodlette Rd N, Naples

Hogfish Harry’s Restaurant + Bar

Tucked back in the gardens of Park Shore Resort is Hogfish Harry’s Restaurant & Bar, and as you can probably tell by the name, is primarily a seafood restaurant.

But hidden on its menu is one of the best burgers Naples FL has to offer.

Hogfish Harry’s Restaurant + Bar’s simple Cheeseburger is bursting with flavor.

Every single element is high quality from the brisket short rib blend patty to the toasted brioche bun to the smoked bacon shallot jam.

You’d be hard-pressed to find a better burger in town.

There’s just one thing that could improve this burger, and that’s a better name!

Hey Harry, are you listening?

Park Shore Resort, 600 Neapolitan Way, Naples

Jimmy P’s Charred

If you’re looking for the best beef in town, look no further than Jimmy P’s, and we’re not talking just burgers.

This Naples business actually started as a butcher shop and is the place to go for all the best cuts.

And since their butchery is still booming, you know the meat in the burgers at Jimmy P’s Charred is top-notch!

An entire section of the menu at Jimmy P’s Charred showcases awesome wagyu craft burgers.

Enjoy the Bacon & Cheddar burger, the Swiss burger, or the Brew City BBQ burger.

But the best burger at Jimmy P’s Charred may be the Jalapeño and Jack burger, especially if you’re a fan of spicy foods. The combo is one of the best we’ve had!

1839 Tamiami Trail N, Naples

***Whether you’re looking for a classic burger with lettuce, tomato, and American cheese or one that’s a bit more unique, the best burger joints in Naples, Florida won’t disappoint.

Now, it’s up to you to decide which of these 8 spots has the best burger in Naples, Florida.